Rallying to Recovery

“I went to block a ball, and I realized that I hurt my thumb. It wasn’t a loud pop or anything, but I could just feel it was really jammed. That’s when I just put it behind my back and just walked off the court. They tried to pop it back in place but it wouldn’t go, so they took me to a hospital. They had to call in different specialists, surgeons and all these different people to check it out. No one could get it back in place. It was the weirdest thing ever. It looked horrible. You would think that my thumb was not even attached in any way.”

An action shot of Alli during a volleyball game, a millisecond after hitting a volleyball with her two hands held closely together. She is looking up and away, in the direction that the ball is going.
Alli is a powerful player: in her first season with UK Volleyball, she was named SEC freshman of the year.

Talking to Alli Stumler, you’d never know how badly she hurt herself while trying out for the USA Collegiate National team in February of 2020. During the tryouts in Colorado, Alli—a sophomore on the University of Kentucky volleyball team—dislocated her thumb so severely that she required surgery that night to prevent cartilage death around her thumb. That injury threatened her chance to make it onto the USA Collegiate National Team—and the future of her promising volleyball career.

Dr. Maureen O’Shaughnessy, a young-looking white woman with long, wavy brown hair, smiles at the camera. She is sitting and wearing a white lab coat. We see her from the shoulders up.
“The joy of being a hand surgeon is being able to get someone back to doing the things they love,” said Dr. O’Shaughnessy.

The doctors that Alli had seen in Colorado were optimistic that she could return to the court in just four to six weeks. Unfortunately, that meant she wouldn’t be returning to the tryouts or playing at a national level that season. After flying home, Alli met Dr. Maureen O’Shaughnessy, an orthopaedic hand surgeon at UK HealthCare Orthopaedic Surgery & Sports Medicine. Upon getting Alli’s MRI results, Dr. O’Shaughnessy found that the damage to Alli’s thumb was much more extensive than her original surgeons had realized: both the inner and outer ligaments were torn so badly that she required a second surgery nearly two weeks later. 

A computer screen showing X-rays of two hands held close together.
“If you have just one thing out of place, it can dramatically impact how your hands work,” said Dr. O’Shaughnessy.

“I elected to use a state-of-the-art orthopedic implant to reconstruct Alli’s thumb,” Dr. O’Shaughnessy said. “This consists of a bioabsorbable suture anchor to help reconstruct the ligaments and capsule around the thumb joint. This allows the body to rebuild the ligaments on its own. With time, the body breaks down the material, leaving nothing behind. Alli’s surgery went very well and she did great in her postoperative course. Alli is an extremely motivated patient. She worked diligently with her hand therapists and wore her splint appropriately, adhering to the protocols we set for her. Because of this, she has almost a stronger thumb than when she started.”

“Dr. O’Shaughnessy has been amazing,” said Alli. “She’s just the greatest woman. She has such great confidence, and you can tell that she’s so knowledgeable.”

An action shot of Alli and her teammates during a game. Alli is smiling broadly and laughing.
“I love sports and I'm a true competitor—I just think it's so fun to get after it,” said Alli.

After her second surgery, Alli began a very gradual physical therapy routine to restore strength and full mobility in her left thumb. Today, Alli is cleared to play volleyball while wearing a small brace. In the near future, she should be completely healed to play with a small amount of athletic tape. Throughout Alli’s injury and recovery process, she’s remained determined to be the athlete and the teammate that she always has been—with a whole new perspective.

Alli stands at the end of a line of teammates during a game. They are all looking out at the court and clapping.
Even while she was out of the game, Alli remained a part of the team, attending practices and cheering on her teammates.

“It’s really easy to focus on yourself, but I think it’s so much more important to focus on what you are bringing to the team, even if that means you’re injured or you’ll never play again. It’s all about perspective. There’s some days when you’re only going to feel the ‘poor me’s’, and that’s totally fine. You have people in your corner who are going to lift you up. But, it’s really important to have more days of encouraging and being a great teammate.”

An action shot of Alli during a game, jumping impossibly high in the air to spike the volleyball. Her entire torso is above the heads of her teammates.
“Each year, we’re getting closer to getting to the Final Four and winning a championship,” Alli said.

While the COVID-19 pandemic has affected the season, Alli is already planning to return to the court with UK’s volleyball team. And despite her injury, she was named to the national team, which was due to play in July before it was also cancelled due to the pandemic. But regardless of when volleyball resumes, Alli is confident in getting back onto the court, just as Dr. O’Shaughnessy is confident in her ability to get there. “It’s a joy to work with athletes who treat their bodies and their recovery with such respect and determination. Alli did tremendously well. It was a really bad injury, but she’s done remarkably well. It’s already back to better than she was before.”

A portrait of Alli standing against a white backdrop, holding a volleyball between her palms. She looks determined and strong.
“Nothing’s going to get handed to you,” said Alli. “You really have to work for everything.”

See how we care for athletes like Alli

at UK HealthCare Orthopaedic Surgery & Sports Medicine.

A portrait shot of Jaida Garrett, a smiling young Black woman with curly black hair pulled back into a bun with front braids. The lower half of her body is in the pool, while her arms are crossed in front of her and her chin rests on her hands.Doug Morris, a tall, wiry, older white man wearing a cycling jersey covered with international flags, stands behind a bike in his home. The wall behind him is covered in triathlon posters.